An Unsuitable Job - Book Review

Inspired by the classic style of Agatha Christie, Bonnie Hardy's An Unsuitable Job is a cozy mystery that breathes life into the historical legacy of the Harvey Girls. The novel is set between 1929 and 1930 in the burgeoning town of Las Vegas, New Mexico, focusing on the expansive hospitality and tourism empire of Fred Harvey. Against the backdrop of his renowned hotels and restaurants, the story highlights the experiences of the young women who were meticulously trained to deliver exclusive, civilized service within the rugged and desolate landscapes of the far West. By blending these historical accounts with a suspenseful narrative, Hardy captures a unique era of growth and refinement on the frontier.

Throughout the narrative, Josie is depicted as a fiercely independent thinker who must confront the pervasive discrimination of the era and the unique restrictions imposed by the "American Plan" service model. As the harsh economic realities of the Great Depression begin to settle over the region, the financial strain deeply impacts the Fred Harvey empire and shapes the desperate behaviors of both visiting tourists and local residents alike. In the midst of this social upheaval, Josie remains a frequently misunderstood figure, struggling to assert her authority in what society deems an entirely "unsuitable" professional role for a woman.

Josie is truly an inspiration, a character who embodies courage and resilience. Readers will admire her bravery as she relentlessly seeks the truth, even in the face of resistance, and demands honesty from those around her. Her determination to prove her capabilities in a society shaped by the rigid expectations and challenges of this historical period is both admirable and deeply empowering. Set against the backdrop of the "old west," Josie's journey challenges the cultural norms of her time, offering readers a powerful message about facing cultural and societal obstacles with grace, tenacity, and perseverance. Her story not only captivates but also encourages modern readers to approach their own challenges with similar resolve. With her resourcefulness and grit, Josie has all the makings of a compelling detective, leaving readers eagerly anticipating future mysteries and whodunits set in this unique and evocative era.